Effective Solutions And Best Enzymes For Composting Toilet Maintenance

Shopping for best enzymes for composting toilet gets messy because the listings rarely compete on one clean spec.

Choosing the right additive depends on your specific setup. I have categorized these products by their primary function, whether you need active enzyme formulas for waste digestion or natural materials like wood pellets to manage moisture and airflow, to help you match the right maintenance routine to your toilet’s capacity.

Table of Contents

⚡ Quick Verdict

Top Pick

Solbio Compost Toilet Cleaner (0.5L) - Natural, Ec

Solbio Compost Toilet Cleaner (0.5L) – Natural, Ec
Solbio provides a highly effective, plant-based enzyme formula that balances waste breakdown with environmental safety.

View on Amazon

Runner-Up

Bioda Multi-Purpose Probiotic Enzyme Cleaner and D

Bioda Multi-Purpose Probiotic Enzyme Cleaner and D
Bioda offers a versatile, long-lasting probiotic solution that excels at odor control and deep cleaning.

View on Amazon

List of Best Enzymes For Composting Toilet

Image Product Score Link
OGO Origin Composting Toilet - 12V Electric, Urine-Diverting OGO Origin Composting Toilet – 12V Electric, Urine-Diverting
👑 Premium Pick
9.5/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
Solbio Compost Toilet Cleaner (0.5L) - Natural, Eco-Friendly Solbio Compost Toilet Cleaner (0.5L) – Natural, Eco-Friendly
🏆 Editor’s Pick
9.2/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
Bioda Multi-Purpose Probiotic Enzyme Cleaner and Deodorizer, Bioda Multi-Purpose Probiotic Enzyme Cleaner and Deodorizer,
🥈 Runner-Up
8.9/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
Odor Beware Composting Toilet Sawdust Mix - 3 Pounds - All N Odor Beware Composting Toilet Sawdust Mix – 3 Pounds – All N 8.3/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
LEIFIDE 1.76 Pounds Composting Toilet Sawdust All Natural No LEIFIDE 1.76 Pounds Composting Toilet Sawdust All Natural No 8.2/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
LEIFIDE 12 Pcs Composting Toilets Coconut Coir Disks, Coir S LEIFIDE 12 Pcs Composting Toilets Coconut Coir Disks, Coir S 8.0/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
Toilet Sawdust Compost Composting 4.4 Pounds Kit with 8 Gall Toilet Sawdust Compost Composting 4.4 Pounds Kit with 8 Gall 7.9/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
Green Gobbler 5-in-1 Foaming Toilet Bowl Cleaner + Pipe Buil Green Gobbler 5-in-1 Foaming Toilet Bowl Cleaner + Pipe Buil
💵 Budget Pick
7.8/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
LEIFIDE 2 lb Composting Toilet Pellets, Natural Wood Pellets LEIFIDE 2 lb Composting Toilet Pellets, Natural Wood Pellets 7.5/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns
Black Diamond Stoneworks Septic Boost Toilet Bowl Cleaner - Black Diamond Stoneworks Septic Boost Toilet Bowl Cleaner – 7.4/10 View on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns

📋 How We Evaluated

Products were assessed based on their enzymatic activity, environmental safety, and ease of application. We also considered build materials and suitability for various off-grid waste management scenarios.

Detailed Reviews

1

OGO Origin Composting Toilet – 12V Electric, Urine-Diverting👑 Premium Pick

9.5/10
OGO Origin Composting Toilet - 12V Electric, Urine-Diverting
Dimensions 15×16 inches
Power 12V electric agitator
System Urine-diverting
Capacity 25-30 uses

What We Found

The OGO Origin Composting Toilet is a high-end, electric solution for tight living spaces. Its 15-inch by 16-inch footprint makes it perfect for Sprinter vans, boats, and tiny homes. The standout feature is the 12V push-button agitator, which eliminates the need for manual cranking after every use.

By diverting urine into a separate 2.4-gallon bottle, it keeps solids dry in the rear bin, significantly reducing odors. Built in the USA from durable polypropylene, this unit is designed to withstand the rigors of full-time off-grid life.

Its quiet ventilation fan and modern aesthetic make it feel like a standard household appliance rather than a campsite workaround. It offers a truly civilized experience for those living on the road.

💬 My Take

The OGO Origin is the ultimate upgrade for off-grid living, offering unmatched convenience and a modern, compact design.

Who It’s For

This is for the serious van lifer, boat owner, or tiny house dweller who refuses to compromise on comfort. If you have the budget for a premium, electric solution and want to avoid the mess of manual crank systems, this is the best option.

It is perfect for couples or full-time travelers who need a reliable, low-maintenance, and odor-free toilet that fits into a compact, professional-grade build.

✅ Pros
  • Compact footprint fits in very tight spaces.
  • Electric agitator removes the need for manual cranking.
  • Urine-diverting design minimizes odors effectively.
❌ Cons
  • High initial cost compared to simple toilets.
  • Requires 12V power connection.
  • More complex installation than manual units.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

2

Solbio Compost Toilet Cleaner (0.5L) – Natural, Eco-Friendly🏆 Editor’s Pick

9.2/10
Solbio Compost Toilet Cleaner (0.5L) - Natural, Eco-Friendly
Volume 0.5L
Base Plant-based enzymes
Safety Septic safe
Composition 100% natural and organic

What We Found

Solbio offers a comprehensive 100% natural formula designed for both composting and portable toilets. This cleaner utilizes plant extracts, essential oils, and citric acid to break down organic waste effectively. It avoids harmful chemicals like formaldehyde, making it safe for septic systems and the environment.

The liquid formula is easy to pour, providing a straightforward maintenance routine for campers and off-grid users. By focusing on biological waste support, it helps reduce waste volume over time. The inclusion of essential oils ensures that the toilet environment remains pleasant during use.

Its biodegradable nature makes it a responsible choice for those who frequently visit campsites or areas with strict chemical disposal regulations. This cleaner serves as a reliable, eco-conscious alternative to traditional blue chemical treatments.

💬 My Take

Solbio stands out as the most reliable and environmentally friendly choice for daily composting toilet maintenance.

Who It’s For

This product is ideal for eco-conscious campers, van lifers, and off-grid residents who prioritize sustainability. It suits those using portable cassette toilets or basic composting systems who need a reliable, septic-safe solution. Families will appreciate the lack of harsh chemicals, making it safer for frequent handling.

If you frequent campsites with strict environmental policies, Solbio provides the necessary performance without violating disposal rules. It is perfect for those who want a simple, liquid-based maintenance routine that keeps their waste system functional and odor-neutral.

✅ Pros
  • Contains zero harmful chemicals or formaldehyde.
  • Safe for septic systems and the environment.
  • Uses pleasant natural essential oils for odor control.
❌ Cons
  • Requires consistent usage for optimal waste breakdown.
  • Limited volume per bottle for heavy-duty users.
  • Less effective on heavy mineral buildup.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

3

Bioda Multi-Purpose Probiotic Enzyme Cleaner and Deodorizer,🥈 Runner-Up

8.9/10
Bioda Multi-Purpose Probiotic Enzyme Cleaner and Deodorizer,
Volume 1 Gallon
Action Probiotic enzyme breakdown
Longevity Active up to 21 days
Scent Lemon and sage

What We Found

Bioda Multi-Purpose Probiotic Enzyme Cleaner delivers a powerful, long-lasting cleaning action. Its specialized probiotics remain active for up to 21 days, continuing to break down proteins and fats in hard-to-reach areas. This versatility allows it to function as a toilet cleaner, drain maintainer, and general deodorizer.

The enzyme blend digests organic waste until it is fully eliminated, preventing residue buildup. Its lemon and sage fragrance provides a fresh scent without relying on harsh artificial chemicals. The one-gallon size offers significant value for users who need a robust solution for regular maintenance in cabins or homes.

By eliminating the source of odors rather than just masking them, it ensures a cleaner, more hygienic environment for all surfaces and waste systems.

💬 My Take

Bioda is an incredibly versatile and powerful cleaner that provides professional-grade results for various household waste systems.

Who It’s For

This cleaner is best for homeowners or cabin dwellers who need a heavy-duty, multi-purpose solution. It is perfect for those who want to maintain septic systems, drain lines, and toilet bowls with a single, effective product.

If you struggle with persistent odors in your bathroom or kitchen, the probiotic action provides a deep clean that standard cleaners miss. It is also suitable for those who prioritize long-lasting performance and value, as the concentrated gallon size lasts through many applications.

✅ Pros
  • Probiotics continue working long after initial application.
  • Highly versatile for toilets, drains, and surfaces.
  • Eliminates odor at the source naturally.
❌ Cons
  • Large bottle size may be bulky for small van builds.
  • Not specifically formulated only for composting toilets.
  • Price point is higher for initial investment.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

4

Odor Beware Composting Toilet Sawdust Mix – 3 Pounds – All N

8.3/10
Odor Beware Composting Toilet Sawdust Mix - 3 Pounds - All N
Weight 3 Pounds
Ingredients Hardwood sawdust, mineral mix, herb/spice extract
Function Odor neutralizer and liquid absorbent
Safety 100% natural

What We Found

Odor Beware is a specialized 3-pound mix designed to neutralize odors and absorb liquids in portable toilets. It features a blend of hardwood sawdust, a proprietary mineral mix, and a natural herb and spice extract.

This combination works to absorb gases, soak up liquids, and keep bacteria like Salmonella and E. coli at bay. The hardwood base visually hides waste, while the minerals add necessary carbon for composting.

Free from toxins, glues, or painted wood, this is a safe, all-natural option for managing decaying matter or sewage. Its ability to trap gases makes it highly effective for those struggling with persistent odors in small, enclosed spaces. It is a robust, natural alternative to chemical-based deodorizers.

💬 My Take

Odor Beware is a powerful, naturally formulated neutralizer that excels at handling tough odors in portable waste systems.

Who It’s For

This mix is best for those dealing with significant odor issues in their portable or composting toilet. It is perfect for users who want an all-natural, high-performance product that goes beyond basic sawdust to actively trap gases and inhibit bacteria.

If you need a more advanced odor neutralizer that is still environmentally safe, this is a great, specialized choice for your setup.

✅ Pros
  • Active ingredients trap gases and inhibit bacteria.
  • All-natural composition is safe for the environment.
  • Hardwood base effectively hides waste visually.
❌ Cons
  • More expensive than standard plain sawdust.
  • Scent may be strong for some users.
  • Not a substitute for proper ventilation.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

5

LEIFIDE 1.76 Pounds Composting Toilet Sawdust All Natural No

8.2/10
LEIFIDE 1.76 Pounds Composting Toilet Sawdust All Natural No
Weight 1.76 Pounds
Material 100% organic wood shavings
Function Odor control and moisture management
Chemicals None

What We Found

LEIFIDE Sawdust provides a fundamental, natural solution for composting toilet management. Made from 100% organic wood shavings, it contains no chemical additives or impurities. Its structure is scientifically proportioned to offer excellent air permeability and water absorption.

This helps regulate compost humidity and accelerates the decomposition of waste while effectively reducing odor. The 1.76-pound bag is portable and easy to store, making it a convenient option for camping or small-scale composting setups.

As a dry cover material, it is cost-effective and provides a clean, hygienic finish after each use. Its high-quality wood composition ensures that it remains fluffy and light, facilitating even coverage and efficient airflow throughout the solid waste container.

💬 My Take

LEIFIDE Sawdust is a reliable, no-nonsense cover material that keeps composting toilets clean through simple physical absorption.

Who It’s For

This product is best for users of basic composting toilets who prefer an all-natural, chemical-free cover material. It is ideal for campers and off-grid enthusiasts who need a reliable, lightweight option for odor control and moisture management.

If you are looking for an economical way to maintain your compost toilet without complex chemicals, these wood shavings are a perfect, simple solution for your daily routine.

✅ Pros
  • Completely natural with no chemical additives.
  • Excellent water absorption and air permeability.
  • Lightweight and easy to transport for camping.
❌ Cons
  • Requires manual application after every use.
  • Limited mass for high-frequency usage scenarios.
  • Lacks enzymatic breakdown agents.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

6

LEIFIDE 12 Pcs Composting Toilets Coconut Coir Disks, Coir S

8.0/10
LEIFIDE 12 Pcs Composting Toilets Coconut Coir Disks, Coir S
Quantity 12 Disks
Material Coconut bran
Format Expandable disks
Benefit Moisture control and airflow

What We Found

LEIFIDE Coconut Coir Disks offer a compact and effective way to manage moisture in composting toilets. Each disk expands upon adding water, creating a breathable, absorbent base that helps neutralize odors. The coconut bran material is high-quality and easy to break apart, ensuring a consistent texture.

By improving airflow within the solid waste container, these disks accelerate the decomposition process and keep the contents dry. The 12-piece package provides enough material for frequent replacements or extended trips. Their small size makes them exceptionally easy to store in tight spaces, such as van conversions or boats.

This product is a practical, space-saving alternative to bulky bags of sawdust or shavings for those with limited storage capacity.

💬 My Take

These coir disks are the ultimate space-saving solution for moisture control in small-footprint composting toilets.

Who It’s For

This is an excellent choice for those living in vans, boats, or small tiny homes where storage space is extremely limited. If you prefer a lightweight, compact material that only expands when you need it, these coir disks are ideal.

They are also suitable for users who want to improve the overall composting efficiency of their toilet system through better moisture management and airflow.

✅ Pros
  • Highly compact for easy storage and transport.
  • Excellent at neutralizing odors and absorbing moisture.
  • Natural material promotes efficient waste decomposition.
❌ Cons
  • Requires water preparation before use.
  • Can be messy if not handled carefully during expansion.
  • Requires consistent monitoring of moisture levels.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

7

Toilet Sawdust Compost Composting 4.4 Pounds Kit with 8 Gall

7.9/10
Toilet Sawdust Compost Composting 4.4 Pounds Kit with 8 Gall
Total Weight 4.4 Pounds
Included 2 sawdust bags, 4 biodegradable bags
Material Natural wood shavings
Application Indoor and outdoor portable toilets

What We Found

This 4.4-pound kit provides a complete refill solution for composting toilets. It includes two bags of natural sawdust litter and four biodegradable 8-gallon bags, ensuring you have everything needed for waste management. The loose sawdust is highly absorbent and spreads evenly, which helps lock in moisture and odors quickly.

By improving airflow within the toilet bin, it accelerates the breakdown of organic waste. This kit is specifically designed for mobile and outdoor setups where odor control is a top priority.

Because the materials are all-natural and chemical-free, they are safe for composting and do not introduce toxins into the environment. It is a convenient, all-in-one refill pack for campers, RV owners, and off-grid dwellers.

💬 My Take

The complete kit offers excellent convenience and value, making it a great choice for those needing a comprehensive refill solution.

Who It’s For

This kit is ideal for those who want a simple, all-in-one supply of cover material and waste bags. It is perfect for campers, RV enthusiasts, and van lifers who need a reliable, natural method to manage their composting toilet.

If you want to avoid shopping for supplies separately, this kit offers a complete, easy-to-use solution that keeps your toilet system fresh and functional during your travels.

✅ Pros
  • Complete kit simplifies supply management.
  • Biodegradable bags included for easy disposal.
  • Highly absorbent sawdust manages odors well.
❌ Cons
  • Bags may not fit all specific toilet models.
  • Requires manual application of sawdust.
  • Bulkier storage than pellets.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

8

Green Gobbler 5-in-1 Foaming Toilet Bowl Cleaner + Pipe Buil💵 Budget Pick

7.8/10
Green Gobbler 5-in-1 Foaming Toilet Bowl Cleaner + Pipe Buil
Uses 2 applications
Formula Enzyme-enhanced powder
Safety Septic and pipe safe
Scent Fresh lime

What We Found

Green Gobbler 5-in-1 Foaming Toilet Bowl Cleaner is an enzyme-enhanced formula that tackles stains and pipe buildup. The foaming action reaches into nooks and crannies, ensuring a thorough clean without manual scrubbing. It effectively breaks down organic matter, hard water deposits, and mineral buildup while leaving a fresh lime scent.

Because it is safe for septic systems, it works well for those using toilets connected to sensitive waste management setups. The enzymes continue to work after the initial flush, providing ongoing cleaning performance.

This product is a convenient solution for maintaining both the bowl and the pipes leading to your waste system, preventing clogs and keeping the plumbing running smoothly.

💬 My Take

Green Gobbler provides a quick, effective enzymatic clean that protects your septic system and keeps pipes clear.

Who It’s For

This is perfect for homeowners or those with RVs connected to septic systems who want a low-effort cleaning routine. If you deal with hard water stains and want a product that also helps maintain your pipes, this is a great choice.

It is ideal for those who value convenience and effective, enzymatic cleaning power without needing harsh chemicals like bleach.

✅ Pros
  • Foaming action cleans hard-to-reach areas.
  • Enzymes provide long-lasting cleaning results.
  • Safe for septic systems and plumbing.
❌ Cons
  • Only provides two uses per pack.
  • Not intended for long-term waste composting.
  • Requires water access for foaming action.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

9

LEIFIDE 2 lb Composting Toilet Pellets, Natural Wood Pellets

7.5/10
LEIFIDE 2 lb Composting Toilet Pellets, Natural Wood Pellets
Weight 2 Pounds
Material Natural wood pellets
Application Cover material for dry toilets
Fragrance None

What We Found

LEIFIDE Composting Toilet Pellets offer a clean and convenient cover material for dry toilet systems. These wood pellets are designed to absorb surface moisture and cover waste after each use, effectively reducing odors without added fragrances.

The 2-pound bag is compact and easy to transport, making it suitable for RV trips, van life, or emergency sanitation kits. When moisture is present, the pellets break down into a sawdust-like consistency, creating a barrier that keeps waste out of sight.

This makes them a versatile refill option for urine-diverting or bucket toilets. Their consistent quality ensures that they provide reliable moisture management and odor control without the mess of loose shavings.

💬 My Take

These pellets are a clean and efficient way to manage moisture and odor in portable dry toilet systems.

Who It’s For

This product is best for van lifers, RV owners, and boaters who need a clean, easy-to-store cover material. It is ideal for those who prefer pellets over loose sawdust because they are easier to pour and less likely to create dust.

If you want a reliable, no-frills solution for your portable toilet that helps manage moisture and odor during your travels, these pellets are an excellent fit.

✅ Pros
  • Easy to store, pour, and transport.
  • Absorbs moisture and reduces odors effectively.
  • Provides a clean, dust-free cover layer.
❌ Cons
  • Less effective at accelerating decomposition than enzymes.
  • Requires regular replenishment after each use.
  • Smaller capacity than bulk wood shavings.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

10

Black Diamond Stoneworks Septic Boost Toilet Bowl Cleaner –

7.4/10
Black Diamond Stoneworks Septic Boost Toilet Bowl Cleaner -
Volume 1 Quart
Formula Enzyme-powered
Use Toilet cleaner and septic support
Safety Plumbing and septic safe

What We Found

Black Diamond Stoneworks Septic Boost offers a dual-action approach to bathroom maintenance. It cleans toilet bowls by removing stains and residue while simultaneously supporting septic health through an enzyme-powered formula.

This makes it a great choice for properties that rely on septic tanks, as it ensures that the breakdown of organic waste continues efficiently. It is safe for all standard toilet components and plumbing, providing a worry-free cleaning experience.

The liquid formula is easy to apply and leaves the bowl looking refreshed. By combining cleaning and maintenance in one product, it simplifies the care of your home’s waste management system, ensuring that everything stays functional and odor-free over the long term.

💬 My Take

Black Diamond provides an effective, integrated solution for keeping toilets clean and septic systems healthy.

Who It’s For

This product is perfect for homeowners, cabin owners, and RV users whose toilets are connected to a septic system. If you want to maintain your toilet bowl while ensuring the health of your septic tank, this is a very efficient choice.

It is ideal for those who prefer a single product that handles both cosmetic cleaning and essential system maintenance without requiring specialized knowledge.

✅ Pros
  • Combines bowl cleaning with septic system maintenance.
  • Removes stains and buildup effectively.
  • Safe for all types of plumbing and septic systems.
❌ Cons
  • Not designed for direct use in composting bins.
  • Requires liquid disposal which may not suit all dry toilets.
  • Requires regular application for system health.

View Price on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

What to Look For Before Buying

Choosing the right maintenance product depends on your toilet type and lifestyle. You must balance odor control, ease of waste breakdown, and environmental safety. Consider storage constraints and your frequency of use when selecting your supplies.

Check Determine Your System Type

Start by identifying if you have a composting, urine-diverting, or portable cassette toilet. Composting systems often require dry cover materials like sawdust or coir to balance humidity. Cassette toilets generally perform better with liquid enzymatic cleaners that break down solids. Understanding your system ensures you pick compatible additives.

Never use chemicals in a system meant for composting.

Value Analyze Storage and Portability

Consider where you will store your supplies, especially if living in a van or boat. Compact options like coir disks save significant space compared to bulky sawdust bags. If weight is a concern, pellets offer a concentrated, easy-to-carry alternative. Always prioritize products that fit your limited storage footprint.

Proper storage keeps your materials dry and ready for use.

Rating Prioritize Ingredient Safety

Look for biodegradable and septic-safe formulas to protect the environment. Natural enzymes and wood-based materials are generally safer than harsh chemical treatments. Avoid products containing formaldehyde or strong artificial fragrances that mask odors without eliminating them. Environmentally friendly choices ensure you can safely dispose of waste at campsites.

Always verify disposal rules in your area.

Verify Evaluate Odor Control Needs

Assess how effective the product is at neutralizing odors versus masking them. Products that absorb moisture and trap gases typically provide better long-term odor control. Enzymatic cleaners are superior for breaking down the source of smells in cassette tanks.

Consistent use of a quality cover material is essential for dry systems. Test a small amount to see how it handles your specific setup.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use household cleaners in a composting toilet?

Avoid standard household cleaners, as they often contain harsh chemicals that kill the beneficial bacteria needed for composting. Stick to enzyme-based cleaners specifically designed for septic systems or composting toilets. These products effectively break down waste without harming the natural decomposition process.

How often should I add cover material?

Add a layer of cover material after every solid waste use to ensure proper moisture management. The thickness of the layer should be enough to completely cover the waste. This practice is crucial for minimizing odors and maintaining a hygienic toilet bin.

Are enzymes better than sawdust for odor?

Enzymes are more effective for liquid-based cassette toilets, while sawdust is superior for dry composting systems. Enzymes accelerate the breakdown of sludge in tanks, whereas sawdust absorbs moisture and traps gas in solid waste bins. Choose the material that matches your toilet’s specific design.

Do I need to clean the toilet bin regularly?

Even with enzyme treatments, you should perform a deep clean of the bin whenever you empty it. Use a mild, biodegradable soap or a specialized composting toilet cleaner. This prevents buildup and ensures the system remains sanitary over the long term.

Is a urine-diverting toilet less smelly?

Yes, urine-diverting toilets are generally less smelly because they separate liquids from solids. Moisture is the primary driver of odor in composting toilets, so keeping solids dry significantly reduces the smell. This design makes management much easier for full-time off-grid users.

🎯 Final Verdict

For most off-grid users, the Solbio Compost Toilet Cleaner is the definitive top pick due to its superior enzyme-based performance and environmental safety. It simplifies waste management while ensuring your toilet remains hygienic and odor-free.

For those seeking a high-tech, space-saving solution, the OGO Origin Composting Toilet is a premium alternative that offers unmatched convenience with its electric agitator. Both products effectively address the most common composting toilet challenges.

Invest in the right maintenance tools today to upgrade your off-grid experience and ensure a more comfortable, sanitary daily routine.

View Our Top Pick on Amazon
Free Shipping & 30-Day Returns Available

Kara Nesvig

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *